House: Complete 2010 Outlook

Here is the list of House incumbents to watch in the 2010 election. I am listing all of the incumbents that received less than 60% of the vote. I will include the Cook Partisan Voting Index for each district when all the final results are in, and update the list of challengers as time goes on between now and the 2010 filing deadlines in each state.

NOTE: As the 2010 election gets closer, some incumbents could be taken off of this list while others are added. John Barrow (D-GA) and Joe Courtney (D-CT) were considered vulnerable early this year because of their razor-thin wins in 2006, but later on this year were taken off the GOP’s radar screens. On the other hand, Paul Kanjorski (D-PA) and Henry Brown (R-SC) were not considered vulnerable early this year, but later on they were. And of course some incumbents could retire, either by choice, such as Bud Cramer (D-AL), or by defeat in the primary, such as Wayne Gilchrest (R-MD).

The table is over the flip.

**Charlie Melancon (D-LA) and Niki Tsongas (D-MA) were unopposed in 2008, but won with less than 60% in their previous elections (Melancon 55.0% in 2006 and Tsongas 51.3% in the 2007 special).

Freshmen are in boldface.

Incumbents that are retiring are marked in italics.

House Incumbent % won in 2008 Age on 11/02/2010 Potential challengers
AL-02
Bobby Bright
50.3
58
AL-03
Mike Rogers
53.5
52
AL-05
Parker Griffith
51.5
68
AK-AL
Don Young
50.2
77
AZ-01
Ann Kirkpatrick
55.9
60
AZ-02
Trent Franks
59.4
53
AZ-03
John Shadegg
54.1
61
AZ-05
Harry Mitchell
53.2
70
AZ-08
Gabrielle Giffords
54.7
40
CA-02
Wally Herger
57.5
65
CA-03
Dan Lungren
49.9
64
CA-04
Tom McClintock
50.3
54
CA-11
Jerry McNerney
55.6
59
CA-24
Elton Gallegly
58.4
66
CA-25
Buck McKeon
58.0
72
CA-26
David Dreier
52.9
58
CA-44
Ken Calvert
52.2
57
CA-45
Mary Bono Mack
57.4
49
CA-46
Dana Rohrabacher
52.7
63
CA-48
John Campbell
55.7
55
CA-49
Darrell Issa
58.6
57
CA-50
Brian Bilbray
50.3
59
CA-52
Duncan D. Hunter
56.4
33
CO-04
Betsy Markey
56.1
54
CT-04
Jim Himes
51.6
44
CT-05
Chris Murphy
59.0
37
FL-08
Alan Grayson
52.0
52
FL-12
Adam Putnam
57.5
36
FL-13
Vern Buchanan
55.5
59
FL-14
Connie Mack
59.4
43
FL-15
Bill Posey
53.1
62
FL-18
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen
57.9
58
FL-21
Lincoln Diaz-Balart
57.9
56
FL-22
Ron Klein
54.6
53
FL-24
Suzanne Kosmas
57.2
66
FL-25
Mario Diaz-Balart
53.1
49
GA-08
Jim Marshall
57.2
62
ID-01
Walt Minnick
50.6
68
IL-06
Peter Roskam
57.6
49
IL-08
Melissa Bean
59.9
48
IL-10
Mark Kirk
54.5
51
IL-11
Debbie Halvorson
58.4
52
IL-13
Judy Biggert
53.6
73
IL-14
Bill Foster
57.4
55
IL-18
Aaron Schock
58.9
29
IN-03
Mark Souder
55.0
60
IN-04
Stephen Buyer
59.9
52
IN-09
Baron Hill
57.8
57
IA-02
Dave Loebsack
57.1
57
IA-03
Leonard Boswell
56.2
76
KS-02
Lynn Jenkins
50.6
47
KS-03
Dennis Moore
56.3
65
KY-02
Brett Guthrie
52.6
46
KY-03
John Yarmuth
59.4
63
LA-02
Joseph Cao
49.6
43
LA-03
Charlie Melancon**
55.0 (2006)
63
LA-04
John Fleming
48.1
LA-06
Bill Cassidy
48.1
51
ME-01
Chellie Pingree
54.6
55
MD-01
Frank Kratovil
49.1
42
MD-06
Roscoe Bartlett
57.8
84
MA-05
Niki Tsongas**
51.3 (2007)
64
MI-06
Fred Upton
58.8
57
MI-07
Mark Schauer
48.8
49
MI-08
Mike Rogers
56.4
47
MI-09
Gary Peters
52.1
51
MI-11
Thaddeus McCotter
51.3
45
MN-02
John Kline
57.3
63
MN-03
Erik Paulsen
48.5
45
MN-06
Michele Bachmann
46.4
54
MS-01
Travis Childers
54.4
50
MO-06
Sam Graves
59.4
47
MO-09
Blaine Luetkemeyer
50.0
NE-02
Lee Terry
52.5
48
NV-02
Dean Heller
51.8
50
NV-03
Dina Titus
47.4
60
NH-01
Carol Shea-Porter
51.7
57
NH-02
Paul Hodes
56.4
59
NJ-02
Frank LoBiondo
59.2
64
NJ-03
John Adler
51.7
51
NJ-05
Scott Garrett
56.3
51
NJ-07
Leonard Lance
50.8
58
NM-01
Martin Heinrich
55.7
39
NM-02
Harry Teague
56.0
NY-01
Tim Bishop
58.0
60
NY-03
Peter King
NY-19
John Hall
58.5
62
NY-24
Mike Arcuri
51.4
51
NY-25
Dan Maffei
54.5
42
NY-26
Chris Lee
55.4
NY-29
Eric Massa
50.9
51
NC-05
Virginia Foxx
58.4
67
NC-08
Larry Kissell
55.4
59
NC-10
Patrick McHenry
57.6
35
OH-01
Steven Driehaus
51.0
44
OH-02
Jean Schmidt
45.0
59
OH-07
Steve Austria
58.3
52
OH-10
Dennis Kucinich
56.8
64
OH-12
Pat Tiberi
55.3
48
OH-14
Steve LaTourette
58.3
56
OH-15
Mary Jo Kilroy
45.9
61
OH-16
John Boccieri
54.0
41
OH-18
Zack Space
59.8
49
OR-05
Kurt Schrader
54.3
59
PA-03
Kathy Dahlkemper
51.5
52
PA-04
Jason Altmire
56.0
42
PA-05
Glenn Thompson
56.8
50
PA-06
Jim Gerlach
52.1
55
PA-07
Joe Sestak
59.6
58
PA-08
Patrick Murphy
56.8
37
PA-10
Chris Carney
56.4
51
PA-11
Paul Kanjorski
51.7
73
PA-12
John Murtha
58.1
78
PA-15
Charlie Dent
58.6
50
PA-16
Joseph Pitts
55.9
71
SC-01
Henry Brown
51.9
74
SC-02
Joe Wilson
53.7
63
TN-04
Lincoln Davis
58.8
67
TX-03
Sam Johnson
59.8
80
TX-07
John Culberson
55.9
54
TX-10
Mike McCaul
53.9
48
TX-17
Chet Edwards
53.0
59
TX-22
Pete Olson
52.4
47
TX-23
Ciro Rodriguez
55.8
63
TX-24
Kenny Marchant
55.9
59
TX-27
Solomon Ortiz
57.9
73
TX-32
Pete Sessions
57.2
55
VA-01
Rob Whitman
56.6
51
VA-02
Glenn Nye
52.4
36
VA-04
Randy Forbes
59.6
58
VA-05
Tom Perriello
50.1
36
VA-10
Frank Wolf
58.8
71
VA-11
Gerry Connolly
54.7
60
WA-08
Dave Reichert
52.8
60
WV-02
Shelley Capito
57.1
57
WI-08
Steve Kagen
54.0
60
WY-AL
Cynthia Lummis
52.6
56

78 thoughts on “House: Complete 2010 Outlook”

  1. We are likely going to have to work very hard to defend AL-02, AL-05, CO-04, ID-01, MD-01, NY-24, NY-29, TX-17, VA-02, and VA-05.  If things get 1994 bad, many of these other seats will start weakening as well.  

  2. Apparently she was supposed to retire this year, but the GOP convinced her to stay for one more term. I think that this area could be prime territory in 2010 (if she does retire).  

  3. Some districts don’t really make sense… A lot of the California districts, AZ-02, etc. etc. etc.

    LA-06, Bill Cassidy is a Republican, his name is blue.  And TX-07 comes up twice.  

  4. McCotter is so vulnerable!  We actually have a decent bench in the district, too, despite the less than spectacular candidates we had this year.  Speaker Andy Dillon would be an excellent choice, and he’s term limited, so he needs a new job.  My State Representative, Marc Corriveau, would be competitive, but I just can’t see him leaving Lansing.  There are other various officials who could make a race of it, including Wayne County Commissioner Kevin McNamara and Wayne County Executive Robert Ficano.  It should be a good year for Eleventh District Dems if we can get one of these candidates to run.

  5. On the races out west I’m watching.

    Colorado:

    4th District- As long as Betsy Markey provides good service to her constituents, she’ll be fine. This district may have a “red history”, but it’s trending blue rather quickly. Time is now on Markey’s side. My initial thought is “Leans Democratic”.

    New Mexico:

    1st District- Martin Heinrich should be OK here. This seat is quite blue, and Heinrich has a good ABQ base. My initial rating here has to be “Likely Democratic”.

    2nd District- Harry Teague really surprised me with his BIG win this year! Still, he’ll have some work to do to stay safe & fend off possible GOP challengers. My first thought here is “Leans Democratic”.

    Arizona:

    1st District- Ann Kirkpatrick won nicely this year, but nothing’s really guaranteed here. Hopefully because Kirkpatrick’s used to constituent service, she should be OK. Right now, I’m thinking this “Leans Democratic”.

    3rd District- Is there a Dem in local office we can run? I think Shadegg isn’t as strong as he thought he was. I’m thinking “Likely Republican” right now, and this can quickly be upgraded if we get a quality challenger and/or a Napolitano v. McCain Senate race to boost us downticket.

    5th District- Harry Mitchell looks like a good fit for this district, but he’ll again have to look in the rearview mirror to make sure he’s up for whatever the GOP throws his way. This looks like “Leans Democratic” to me.

    Nevada:

    2nd District- Do we have another Dem to run? Heller isn’t as “invincible” as he thinks he is. And if he leaves this seat open to run for something else, we should take advantage of it. It’s “Likely Republican” right now.

    3rd District- Dina Titus knows this area well. She should be OK. However, we just don’t know what the GOP will do or who they’ll run here. I see it as “Leans Democratic” now.

  6. Very eye opening to see the ages of some of these Congressmen.  The worst-case scenario for the defensive year of 2010 is a regionwide purge of even “safe” Blue Dog Democrats in the South.  If Connecticut was willing to unload Chris Shays and Rob Simmons in anti-Republican years, who’s to say Tennessee wouldn’t choose to do the same to Bart Gordon or Lincoln Davis?

    1. If republicans filibuster many democratic pieces of legislation seen as important to turning the economy around, Obama might have a case to make that republicans are largely responsible.  But it doesn’t seem as though that would be likely.  Voters are more likely to blame the party in control – us.

Comments are closed.